New for 2025 May contain Adult Cutters
 
        Special Offers
- 
      3.5 inch Penis Pecker Party Favor Metal Cookie Cutter Regular price $1.99
- 
      4 inch Penis Pecker Party Favor Metal Cookie Cutter Regular price $1.99
- 
      5 inch Penis Pecker Party Favor Metal Cookie Cutter Regular price $1.99
- 
      6.5 inch Penis Pecker Willy Party Favor Metal Cookie Cutter Regular price $1.99
- 
    New for 2025        1.75 inch Mini Cross Metal Cookie Cutter Elevate your baking with our charming 1.75 inch Mini Cross Metal Cookie Cutter—perfect for baptisms, Easter treats, religious gatherings, or everyday decorating. Size: 1.75″ (44.45 mm) Height of All Cutters: 1″ (25.4 mm) Material: Durable tinplate...Regular price $1.99Regular price $1.99
- 
    New for 2025        2 inch Mini Ugly Sweater Metal Cookie Cutter Bring a cozy, festive touch to your baking with our 2 inch Mini Ugly Sweater Metal Cookie Cutter—perfect for bite-sized treats and fondant accents. Size: Width: 2″ (5.08 cm) Height: 1″ (2.54 cm) (all our cutters...Regular price $1.99Regular price $1.99
- 
    New for 2025        2 inch Mini Turkey or Rooster Metal Cookie Cutter Bring a touch of Thanksgiving charm to every batch of cookies, sandwiches, or fondant decorations with our 2 inch Mini Turkey or Rooster Metal Cookie Cutter. Crafted from sturdy tinplate steel and proudly made in Douglassville,...Regular price $1.99Regular price $1.99
- 
    New for 2025          4 inch Stegosaurus Metal Cookie Cutter Precision‑formed from durable tinplate steel is this iconic 4 inch Stegosaurus Metal Cookie Cutter (2.54 cm) cutting height. Proudly made in Douglassville, PA, USA.Care for Tinplate Cookie Cutters Hand wash only: Gently clean this 4 inch Stegosaurus...Regular price $1.99Regular price $1.99
- 
    New for 2025          4.75 inch Pterodactyl Metal Cookie Cutter 4.75 Inch Pterodactyl Metal Cookie Cutter is a fun and adventurous tool that brings prehistoric charm to your baking projects. Measuring 4.75 inches, this cutter is shaped like the iconic flying reptile, making it perfect for...Regular price $1.99Regular price $1.99
- 
    New for 2025          4 inch Triceratops Metal Cookie Cutter Charge into prehistoric baking fun with this mighty 4 inch Triceratops Metal Cookie Cutter, precision‑formed from sturdy tinplate steel! Measuring 4″ (10.16 cm) from horn tip to tail and standing our signature 1″ (2.54 cm) tall, it easily...Regular price $1.99Regular price $1.99
Step into a fresh year of creativity with our New for 2025 May contain Adult Cutters collection, where timeless craftsmanship meets inspired new designs. Each cutter in this collection is made from high-quality, food-safe metal, designed to deliver clean, precise shapes and dependable performance for years to come. With thoughtful new additions that reflect the beauty of tradition and the excitement of something new, these cutters are perfect for bakers who appreciate both heritage and innovation.
Our New for 2025 May contain Adult Cutters collection features an array of delightful themes—fresh seasonal motifs, charming everyday shapes, and creative designs that spark imagination in every kitchen. Each piece continues our long-standing commitment to quality, offering crisp edges for perfect cuts and lasting durability that bakers have trusted for generations.
Rooted in the same traditional values that define our brand, this collection celebrates what’s new while honoring what’s lasting: the joy of baking from the heart. Whether you’re adding to your collection or discovering a new favorite, these cutters bring inspiration, warmth, and the promise of a year filled with homemade goodness and cherished moments shared around the table.This is the page for the new cutters for 2025. As we make new ones they will appear at the top of the list.
- 
                                
                    
                
                ITEM BAR TITLE Share shipping, delivery, policy information. 
- 
                                
                    
                
                ITEM BAR TITLE Share shipping, delivery, policy information. 
- 
                                
                    
                
                ITEM BAR TITLE Share shipping, delivery, policy information. 
- 
                                
                    
                
                ITEM BAR TITLE Share shipping, delivery, policy information. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
                            
 
                        
                            
                                
 
                            
 
                        
                            
                                
 
                            
 
                        
                            
                                
 
                            
 
                        
                            
                                
 
                            
                         
                            
 
                        
                            
                                
 
                            
                         
                            
 
                        
                            
                                
