The Pros and Cons of Tinplate Steel, Stainless Steel, 3D Printed PLA, and Copper Cookie Cutters

The Pros and Cons of Tinplate Steel, Stainless Steel, 3D Printed PLA, and Copper Cookie Cutters

When selecting the right cookie cutter, material matters. Whether you're honoring a cherished family recipe or crafting unique cookies for sale, understanding the benefits and limitations of each type of cutter will help you choose wisely. Let’s take a closer look at tinplate steel, stainless steel, 3D printed PLA, and copper—each with its own legacy and strengths.

Tinplate Steel Cookie Cutters

The Traditional Workhorse

Pros:

  • Sharp Edges for Precision

  • Affordable for Bulk and Seasonal Sets

  • Vintage Aesthetic and Feel

Cons:

  • Prone to Rust Without Care

  • Shorter Lifespan if Mishandled

  • Not Dishwasher Safe

Stainless Steel Cookie Cutters

The Reliable Everyday Tool

Pros:

  • Rust-Resistant for Longevity

  • Strong and Sturdy

  • Dishwasher Friendly

Cons:

  • More Expensive Than Tinplate

  • Edges May Be Slightly Thicker, Affecting Detail

3D Printed PLA Cookie Cutters

The Creative Frontier

Pros:

  • Fully Customizable Shapes

  • Lightweight and Safe for Gentle Doughs

  • Affordable for Small-Run Designs

Cons:

  • Not Heat-Resistant (Can Warp in Heat)

  • Not as Sharp for Clean Cuts

  • Shorter Lifespan, Especially with Moisture

Copper Cookie Cutters

The Artisan’s Choice

Pros:

  • Elegant Appearance – Copper cookie cutters are undeniably beautiful, often seen as heirloom pieces passed down through generations.

  • Durable and Sturdy – Handmade copper cutters are built with thick bands of metal that resist bending and deformation.

  • Custom Made – Many copper cutters are crafted by artisans, allowing for unique or highly detailed designs.

  • Non-Rusting (if kept dry) – While copper tarnishes, it doesn’t rust like tinplate.

Cons:

  • Expensive – These are often the most costly option due to the material and craftsmanship involved.

  • Requires Polishing – Copper naturally tarnishes and will lose its shine unless cleaned and polished occasionally.

  • Not Dishwasher Safe – Hand washing and drying is a must.

  • Heavier – While this adds to stability, it can be cumbersome in large sizes or frequent use.

Conclusion: Which Cutter Is Right for You?

  • For Tradition: Tinplate is budget-friendly and nostalgic. In all practically tinplate is the way to go.

  • For Durability: Stainless steel stands the test of time.

  • For Customization: 3D printed PLA is ideal for creative designs.

  • For Craftsmanship: Copper cutters offer timeless beauty and artisan quality.

No matter your preference, the heart of cookie cutting lies in the joy it brings—whether that’s through family gatherings, customer smiles, or a tray of perfect gingerbread men cooling on the counter.

Read next

Back to blog